Florida Public Adjusting

Architectural Finish Damage Claims: Floors, Tile, Millwork and Matching

Marble and porcelain floors, coral stone, custom millwork, coffered ceilings, Venetian plaster and specialty paint finishes are expensive to repair and hard to match. When water, wind or fire damages part of a finished surface, the biggest dispute is usually not whether the damage is covered, but how much of the surface must be replaced to restore a uniform look.

  • 4.8/5 Google rating
  • Licensed in Florida, W106037 / W805707
  • No fee unless you get paid
  • Se habla español

How we help

  • Identify materials, grades and installation methods precisely
  • Show where a partial repair cannot match
  • Price specialty trades, not generic line items

Get a free claim review

Tell us what happened. A licensed public adjuster calls you back.

    We use these details only to call you back about your property claim. Sending this form does not file a claim with your insurer and does not sign you up for anything. Privacy Policy.

    Florida Public Adjusting, firm Lic. W805707; Joshua Solomon, Lic. W106037.

    Florida's matching rule

    Florida law addresses this directly. In a homeowners claim, when replaced items do not match in quality, color or size, the insurer must make reasonable repairs or replacement of items in adjoining areas so the result has a reasonably uniform appearance (s. 626.9744, Fla. Stat.). What counts as adjoining and reasonably uniform depends on the layout of the space and the materials, which is why documentation matters.

    Common finish disputes

    • Continuous tile or stone flooring through several rooms, where replacement tiles are discontinued or come from a different dye lot.
    • Wood flooring that cupped in one room but was installed as one continuous floor.
    • Custom cabinetry and millwork where one damaged run cannot be matched in species, profile or finish.
    • Textured or specialty wall and ceiling finishes that cannot be blended.
    • Natural stone countertops where the slab cannot be matched.

    How finishes should be documented

    Record the exact material, size, grade and origin when available, and look for leftover stock, labels and invoices. Where the insurer says a match is available, ask for a physical sample. Specialty work should be priced by the trade that would actually do it, such as a stone fabricator or millwork shop, rather than at a generic per-square-foot rate.

    Finish damage questions

    The adjuster wants to replace only the damaged tiles. What can I do?

    Ask for the source of matching tiles. If none exists, document the continuous area and request replacement consistent with s. 626.9744.

    Does the matching rule apply to condos?

    Section 626.9744 applies to homeowners insurance. In a condo, interior finishes are generally the unit owner's responsibility under the HO-6, with the master policy covering the structure (s. 718.111(11), Fla. Stat.). See condo unit owner claims.

    Is a designer's estimate useful?

    It can be, especially for custom work, alongside contractor bids.

    Get a free claim review

    Tell us what happened. A licensed public adjuster calls you back.

    • 4.8/5 Google rating
    • Licensed in Florida, W106037 / W805707
    • No fee unless you get paid
    • Se habla español

    Prefer to talk? Call (305) 964-8624

      We use these details only to call you back about your property claim. Sending this form does not file a claim with your insurer and does not sign you up for anything. Privacy Policy.

      Florida Public Adjusting, firm Lic. W805707; Joshua Solomon, Lic. W106037.

      Related guides

      Skip to content